3D printing vs CNC milling for orthotics comparison reveals complementary technologies with distinct advantages. 3D printing excels for complex geometries and lower volumes with $15K-$35K investment, while CNC milling provides superior precision and speed for higher volumes with $45K-$65K investment. Professional practices choose based on volume, materials, and workflow requirements.

3D Printing vs CNC Milling for Custom Orthotics

Home / Comparisons / 3D Printing vs CNC

Technology Comparison: 3D Printing vs CNC Milling

Factor	3D Printing	CNC Milling
Initial Investment	$15,000 - $35,000	$45,000 - $65,000
Cost Per Pair	$8 - $15	$4 - $8
Production Speed	2-4 hours per pair	15-25 minutes per pair
Dimensional Accuracy	±0.1-0.2mm	±0.005mm
Material Options	TPU, PETG, Nylon	EVA, PP, Carbon Fiber
Design Complexity	Unlimited geometries	Tool access limits
Ideal Volume	5-15 pairs/day	15+ pairs/day
Operator Skill Required	Minimal	Moderate

Decision Checklist: Which Technology is Right for You?

Choose 3D Printing If:

Your practice produces fewer than 15 orthotics daily
You need complex geometries or lattice structures
Lower initial investment is priority
You prefer minimal operator training
You want to start small and scale gradually

Choose CNC Milling If:

Your practice produces 15+ orthotics daily
Speed and efficiency are critical
You need maximum dimensional accuracy
Lower per-part costs are important
You have higher production volumes

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for orthotic production: 3D printing or CNC milling?

The best choice depends on your practice volume and material requirements. 3D printing excels for complex geometries and lower volumes (5-15 pairs/day), while CNC milling provides superior precision and faster production for higher volumes (15+ pairs/day). Most successful practices choose based on their specific workflow and patient needs.

What are the cost differences between 3D printing and CNC for orthotics?

3D printing has lower equipment costs ($15,000-$35,000) but higher per-pair material costs ($8-15). CNC milling requires higher initial investment ($45,000-$65,000) but lower per-pair costs ($4-8). Break-even typically occurs at 20+ pairs monthly for CNC systems.

Which technology provides better accuracy for custom orthotics?

CNC milling provides superior dimensional accuracy (±0.005mm) compared to 3D printing (±0.1-0.2mm). However, both technologies exceed clinical requirements for orthotic applications. The choice often depends more on material properties and production workflow than pure accuracy.

Can I use the same CAD software for both 3D printing and CNC milling?

Yes, OrthoCAD and similar professional software generate optimized output for both technologies. The software automatically adjusts design parameters and toolpaths based on your selected manufacturing method, ensuring optimal results whether you choose 3D printing or CNC milling.